Banana Cream Pie Cheesecake {with Chobani Greek Yogurt}

About a year ago I made cheesecake for the first time, peppermint hot chocolate cheesecake.  I am not sure why it took me so long to make a homemade cheesecake, they are sooooo delicious!  Most cheesecakes only have cream cheese of course, BUT since I am a Chobani Greek Yogurt addict, mine also contains some creamy dreamy Greek yogurt.

Whenever I go to The Cheesecake Factory, the only cheesecake I can see on the menu…. banana cream pie cheesecake!  I know there are others probably on that menu, but the only one that has my heart is the banana cream pie.  Now that I have made my own version at home….well my waist line may hate me a little more….

This cake was specially made for sweet Nelly from Cooking with Books!  NellyFest2013 is still taking place, and she deserves the best!  This cake brought back lots of happy memories of my many delicious trips to Cheesecake Factory.  I am so excited to finally enjoy a homemade version in the comfort of my home.  Cheers to Nelly, Cheers to delicious cake, and Cheers to happy tummies!!!

Yields 12

Banana Cream Pie Cheesecake

A delicious cheesecake that will melt in your mouth!

30 minPrep Time

70 minCook Time

1 hr, 40 Total Time

Save Recipe


For Crust:
10 oz box of Teddy Graham Chocolate flavor crackers
1/2 cup sugar
3/4 cup melted butter
For Cheesecake:
2 1/2 cups 2% Plain Chobani Greek Yogurt
2 (16oz) cream cheese, softened
1 3/4 cups sugar
5 eggs at room temperature
2 1/2 cups mashed bananas, about three bananas
1 Tbsp vanilla extract
Three bananas sliced and placed on top of crust


Preheat oven to 325 degrees Fahrenheit. Spray 10 inch spring form pan with cooking spray. Cover bottom of pan and around the sides with foil.

In food processor - grind finely the teddy graham chocolate crackers, mix in sugar, and slowly mix in melted butter until well combined.

Spread graham cracker crumb mixture out evenly in spring form pan on bottom and around sides.

In kitchenaid mixer or with hand mixer - mix together Greek yogurt, softened cream cheese, add in sugar, slowly add one egg at a time, make sure cheesecake batter is mixed well, add vanilla extract and mashed bananas, mix well.

Place slice bananas on bottom of cheesecake pan on crust, pour cheesecake batter on top of sliced bananas. Place cheesecake on sheet pan to bake, place in oven, add water to sheet pan just until it covers bottom of pan. A water bath will help cook the cheesecake evenly.

Bake cheesecake for 1 hr and 30 minutes. It will depend on oven, bake until there is no jiggle in center of cheesecake. After hour and half, turn off oven and let cheesecake sit in oven until the oven cools. Then place in refrigerator for up to six hours, or you can blast chill the cheesecake in freezer for about 2 hours.


Recipe Type: Dessert

I seem to keep eating my props……BUT it was soooooo good!

What is your favorite cheesecake?




Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
  • I love cheesecake and this looks amazing! How have I never had banana cream cheesecake before??? My favorite is plain or my chocolate glazed Baileys Irish Cream Cheesecake. Oh, you're making me hungry!!! Will go celebrate with Nelly now :-) xo
  • I d love your banana cream pie for breakfast now, it looks incredible yum! It's ok to have pie for breakfast,right? =P
  • I love that you used greek yogurt in your cheesecake! I will have to try that! :)
  • Hotly Spiced
    That's a fantastic looking cheesecake. It's not something I see here very often. I'd like to give this a try xx
  • cupcakekalechip
    I am not a cheesecake fan, but your LOOKS like it came straight from Cheesecake Factory! Awesome!
  • kitchenriffs
    Great looking cheesecake! I've never eaten at a Cheesecake Factory, so I've been missing this all these years. But no longer! I have the recipe! Looks terrific. Thanks.
  • I think I just found my new favorite cheesecake made with yogurt! It looks sensational, Terra..I wish I had a slice for breakfast! By the way..I' used to be MAJORLY hooked on the Southern Fried Chicken Salad at Cheesecake Factory, even more than the cheesecakes!
  • diabeticFoodie
    I once ordered a Banana Cream Pie cheesecake from Cheesecake Factory for my husband's birthday (we didn't have one anywhere near us). It was delicious. Then we learned each SLICE had more than 1,000 calories! We took the rest of it to work :)
  • Jennie @themessybakerblog
    Terra, this looks amazing! I need a fork.
  • That looks so professional my friend :D Cheers CCU
  • Wow, Terra, you just covered both of my favorite desserts in one dish. This looks amazing....have to pin this one for later!
    Aww Terra you combined here two of my favorites, banana cream pie with cheesecake. How brilliant. Wishing you a great weekend!
  • mjskit @
    I can't believe I have never made a cheesecake, but then I do find them rather heavy at times. This one looks creamy rather than heavy and oh so good. Since banana cream pie is one of my favorite pies, I think this could become my favorite cheese cake!